Websites as Public Accommodations: The Circuit Split

Title III of the Americans with Disabilities Act tells businesses that serve the public not to shut people with disabilities out of their goods and services. When that access happens online, courts have had to answer a question Congress never spelled out in 1990: is a website itself a "place of public accommodation," or does the law only reach a site when it connects to a physical store, restaurant, or office?
Federal appeals courts have not answered that question the same way. The result is often called a circuit split. This article is general information, not legal advice. It explains the main approaches in plain language, notes where the case law actually stands (including the often-misstated history of Gil v. Winn-Dixie), and points to practical steps that still make sense for a small business website.
What Title III says—and what it leaves open
Title III covers "places of public accommodation." The statute lists twelve categories of businesses, from inns and restaurants to stores, offices, and places of recreation. Those categories describe physical establishments. Commercial websites barely existed when the ADA became law, so the text does not mention the web.
That silence left room for disagreement. Some courts read "public accommodation" as limited to tangible places, then ask whether an inaccessible website still blocks access to those places. Others say the point of Title III is equal access to goods and services, whether the sale happens in a storefront or through a browser. The U.S. Department of Justice has long said that the ADA's nondiscrimination and effective-communication rules apply to goods and services that public accommodations offer on the web, including in its March 2022 web accessibility guidance. DOJ has not, however, published a Title III regulation that names a single technical standard for private-business websites the way its Title II rule does for many state and local government sites. For that public-sector timeline, see our post on the DOJ Title II web rule deadlines.
Circuits that treat websites more broadly
A first group of appellate decisions rejects the idea that a public accommodation must be a brick-and-mortar building.
In the First Circuit, Carparts Distribution Center v. Automotive Wholesaler's Ass'n (1994) held that "public accommodation" is not limited to physical structures. That case involved an insurance plan, not a website, but district courts in the circuit later applied the same reasoning to online services—including well-known streaming and e-commerce disputes.
The Seventh Circuit has spoken in a similar spirit. In opinions such as Doe v. Mutual of Omaha and related insurance cases, Judge Posner and colleagues treated "public accommodation" as reaching facilities open to the public in physical or electronic space, and used a website as an example of a covered facility. Those passages are often quoted when courts ask whether a site without a storefront can still fall under Title III.
A 2025 American Bar Association overview of digital accessibility under Title III likewise groups the Second Circuit with courts that have signaled online-only businesses may be covered, while noting that district courts can still disagree until the court of appeals decides a website case directly.
Circuits that require a nexus to a physical place
A second group starts from the statute's list of physical places. Under this reading, a website is not automatically a place of public accommodation. Title III reaches the site when there is a sufficient connection—often called a nexus—between the website and a covered physical location, and when barriers on the site impede access to that location's goods or services.
The Third and Sixth Circuits developed the physical-place and nexus ideas in earlier cases about insurance benefits tied (or not tied) to physical offices. District courts in those circuits have since used that framework in website lawsuits, including recent dismissals where the defendant was treated as online-only with no public-facing store.
The Ninth Circuit is the clearest appellate voice on websites with a storefront link. In Robles v. Domino's Pizza (2019), the court held that Domino's website and app were covered because they connected customers to the goods and services of Domino's physical restaurants. The court stressed that Title III applies to the services of a place of public accommodation, not only services offered inside the building. It did not decide how Title III would treat a business with no physical locations at all. The Supreme Court declined to review the case.
Gil v. Winn-Dixie: important history, not current Eleventh Circuit law
Many articles still cite Gil v. Winn-Dixie Stores as if the Eleventh Circuit settled that websites are never places of public accommodation. The real timeline is more careful.
After a rare trial, a Florida district court found that Winn-Dixie's website was a service of its stores and ordered relief. On appeal in April 2021, a divided Eleventh Circuit panel held that Title III's "public accommodation" language covers physical places, not websites themselves, and that the site at issue was not an intangible barrier to the stores under the facts of that case. Eight months later, in December 2021, the same court vacated that opinion and the underlying judgment because the injunction had expired while the appeal was pending and the dispute had become moot. A vacated opinion has no precedential force.
So as of today, the Eleventh Circuit does not have a published, binding rule answering the website-as-public-accommodation question. Older district decisions and other circuits still influence how courts read the law in that region, but it is inaccurate to treat the vacated Gil panel opinion as the law of the circuit.
Why the split matters for a small business
Where a case is filed can change which theory a court starts from. Plaintiffs often sue in states with active filing patterns and state laws that allow money damages the federal ADA does not. Our roundup of ADA website lawsuits by the numbers shows how concentrated filings are in a few states and how often smaller companies are named.
For an owner, circuit-shopping is a weak planning tool. Customers visit from everywhere, and state laws such as California's Unruh Act can apply even when a federal nexus argument is in play. Settlements and demand letters remain common. The safer question is not "which circuit would dismiss this?" but "can people with disabilities complete the same tasks on our site that everyone else can?"
What calm, useful practice looks like
While courts continue to argue over doctrine, the day-to-day work looks familiar:
- Find barriers on the pages that matter. Home, product or service pages, booking or checkout, contact forms, and login flows. Start with a free automated scan, then check keyboard use and a screen reader on the critical paths.
- Fix high-impact issues in the site's own code and content. Contrast, alternative text, labels, headings, and keyboard access remove a large share of everyday barriers. Our list of 10 quick accessibility fixes is a practical starting checklist.
- Do not treat a toolbar or overlay as the whole plan. Assistive options can help some visitors, but they do not rewrite missing labels or broken focus order in your templates. We explain why in Can a widget alone make a site accessible?
- Publish an honest accessibility statement with a way for visitors to report problems, and respond when they write. See How to write an accessibility statement.
- Keep going after the first pass. New pages, themes, and plugins reintroduce issues. Schedule rescans the way you schedule security updates.
If you are comparing services, our compare pages describe what different approaches cover without sales theatrics.
The bottom line
Federal courts still disagree about whether a website, standing alone, is a Title III place of public accommodation. Some circuits lean toward covering online services without a physical storefront; others focus on a nexus to brick-and-mortar places, as in the Ninth Circuit's Domino's decision. The Eleventh Circuit's well-known Gil website opinion was vacated and does not bind that circuit. DOJ guidance treats web offerings of public accommodations as within the ADA's reach, yet private businesses still lack a Title III technical regulation parallel to the Title II web rule.
For a small business, the practical response is steady improvement of the site itself: remove barriers, test real tasks, document progress, and give visitors a way to ask for help. To see what an automated check finds on your pages today, run a free scan.
Frequently asked questions
Are websites places of public accommodation under the ADA?
It depends on the court. Some circuits treat websites and online services as covered without requiring a physical storefront. Others require a nexus between the website and a brick-and-mortar place of public accommodation. The Department of Justice says Title III reaches goods and services that public accommodations offer on the web.
What is the "nexus" test?
It is the idea that Title III applies to a website when the site connects customers to the goods or services of a physical place of public accommodation, and barriers on the site impede that access. The Ninth Circuit's Domino's decision is a leading example.
Did Gil v. Winn-Dixie settle that websites are not covered?
No. The Eleventh Circuit's April 2021 panel opinion limited Title III to physical places on the facts of that case, but the court vacated that opinion in December 2021 because the appeal became moot. It is not binding precedent.
Is there a federal technical standard for private-business websites under Title III?
Not in a Title III regulation. Courts, settlements, and DOJ materials often look to the Web Content Accessibility Guidelines (WCAG). DOJ's detailed WCAG-based web rule applies to many state and local government sites under Title II, not to private businesses under Title III.
What should a small business do while the circuits disagree?
Improve accessibility on the pages people use to buy, book, or contact you; test with keyboard and assistive technology; publish a clear accessibility statement; and keep fixing issues over time. Guessing which circuit theory will win is not a substitute for removing barriers.
Comparing tools? See our accessibility widget comparison.
Sources
- ADA.gov: Guidance on Web Accessibility and the ADA (March 18, 2022)
- American Bar Association: Digital Accessibility Under Title III of the ADA (Aug 2025)
- Robles v. Domino's Pizza, LLC, 913 F.3d 898 (9th Cir. 2019)
- Gil v. Winn-Dixie Stores, Inc., vacatur order (11th Cir. Dec. 28, 2021)
- Holland & Knight: Eleventh Circuit Vacates Opinion Holding that Websites Are Not ADA Public Accommodations
- Accessibility.build: ADA Website Case Law by Circuit
- 42 U.S.C. § 12181(7) — definition of public accommodation (statutory categories)
Disclaimer: This article is general information, not legal advice. Laws and dates can change. A toolbar alone doesn't make a website conform; we help reduce risk and improve access.