Free scan

← All posts

PDF Accessibility: Fixing Menus, Forms and Flyers on Your Site

Illustration of a laptop showing a menu-style PDF with heading bars and item lines, a phone in front showing a simple form with a checkbox, and circular badges for an image, a check mark, a keyboard and a headset.

Most small business websites have PDFs: the menu, the price list, the new-patient form, the event flyer. They're easy to make and look the same everywhere, which is why owners like them.

The catch is that a PDF can look perfect and still be unusable for someone who relies on a screen reader, a keyboard or text magnification. Here's what makes a PDF accessible, how to check yours for free, and when a web page works better.

Why PDFs trip people up

A web page carries its structure in its code. A heading is marked as a heading, a list is marked as a list, and assistive technology reads that structure out loud. A PDF can carry the same kind of structure, but only if someone put it there. Many are exported in a way that keeps the look and drops the structure.

The result is a document that a sighted mouse user can read with no trouble, while a screen reader user may hear the text in a jumbled order, hear nothing at all, or land on form boxes with no idea what each one is for. And because a PDF doesn't reflow, people who zoom in a lot end up scrolling sideways.

What "accessible PDF" actually means

WebAIM, the nonprofit accessibility group at Utah State University, explains that when people talk about accessible PDFs they're usually talking about tagged PDFs. Tags are labels hidden inside the file that say what each piece of content is and what order it comes in. They don't change how the page looks. WebAIM is also clear that tags aren't the whole story, but that an untagged PDF wouldn't be considered accessible.

WebAIM describes a PDF as having three parts that work together:

Illustration of three stacked copies of the same document page: the top shows the visible page with a heading, text lines and a picture, the middle shows plain text characters, and the bottom shows a branching tree of tags
A PDF has a visual layer, a text layer and a tags layer. Assistive technology depends on the last two.

For a business owner, that boils down to a short list. An accessible PDF has real, selectable text. It's tagged, with headings and lists marked properly. It reads in a logical order. Images that carry meaning have alt text. Tables have header cells. Form fields have labels and can be reached with a keyboard. The document has a title and a language set. And it still makes sense without color, which matters for things like "items in red are gluten-free."

These points line up with the Web Content Accessibility Guidelines (WCAG), which apply to documents as well as web pages. W3C publishes a set of PDF techniques that show how specific WCAG requirements are met inside a PDF. If you want the background on WCAG itself, our plain-English WCAG 2.2 checklist covers the basics.

How to check your PDFs for free

Start with the PDFs people use most. A menu or intake form opened every day matters more than an old newsletter. Check each one like this:

  1. Try to select the text. Open the PDF and drag your cursor across a paragraph. If you can't highlight individual words, it's a scanned image and needs text before anything else.
  2. Run a free checker. PAC, the PDF Accessibility Checker, is a free Windows tool funded by the German Federal Ministry of Labor and Social Affairs. Adobe Acrobat Pro also has a built-in accessibility checker. Both will flag missing tags, missing alt text, missing titles and similar problems.
  3. Look at the reading order yourself. Tools can tell you tags exist, but not always whether they make sense. Use the tags or reading-order view in your PDF editor, or listen to the file with a free screen reader such as NVDA, and make sure it reads top to bottom the way a person would.
  4. Tab through any form. Press the Tab key from the top of the document. Each field should get focus in a sensible order, and a screen reader should announce what each field is for.

The federal government's Section 508 program publishes free PDF testing checklists and a testing and remediation guide on Section508.gov, which are handy if you want a step-by-step list to follow. Web-page testing tools are a separate topic from the PDF checkers above.

Fixing the three PDFs small businesses post most

Menus and price lists

When a multi-column menu is exported carelessly, a screen reader may read every dish name first and every price afterward, with no way to match them up. The best fix is usually to put the menu on a regular web page with real headings for each section, and keep the PDF only as a printable extra. If you keep a PDF, export it with tags turned on, check that each item reads with its price, and don't rely on color or icons alone to mark things like spicy or vegetarian. Add a short text key.

Fillable forms

Intake forms, job applications and order forms are where PDFs most often stop people cold. WebAIM's guidance on accessible forms in Acrobat covers the main points: every field needs a name a screen reader can announce (the "tooltip" field in Acrobat), fields need a logical tab order, and instructions should come before the fields they apply to. Check boxes and radio buttons need labels too. If you can, consider an online form on your website instead. It works on phones and is easier to make accessible.

Flyers and one-page announcements

Flyers are usually one big image with words baked in. That's fine for print, but on your website the same information should also exist as text: either alt text that covers the key details (event name, date, time, place, how to sign up) or, better, a short text version right on the page next to the download link. Our post on accessible colors and fonts also applies here, since light gray text on a photo is hard for many people to read.

When a web page beats a PDF

Section508.gov notes that PDFs are often not the most accessible or mobile-friendly option, and that federal policy asks agencies to use HTML first and PDFs only when necessary. That rule is for federal agencies, but the reasoning carries over to a small business. A web page reflows on a phone, works with zoom, can be found by search engines and is easier to keep current. Our post on how accessibility helps SEO and sales explains why searchable text helps you get found.

What the rules say about documents

The Department of Justice's 2024 rule for state and local governments under Title II of the ADA covers documents such as PDFs on their websites. It has a limited exception for older "preexisting conventional electronic documents," such as a PDF flyer posted before a government's deadline. The DOJ's examples make clear that documents posted or updated after that date generally need to meet WCAG 2.1 Level AA. You can read more in our guide to the Title II deadlines.

Private businesses aren't covered by that rule, and there's no specific federal web regulation for them yet. The DOJ's general web guidance says businesses open to the public should make their websites accessible, and it names WCAG as helpful guidance. Courts differ on how that applies to websites, which we cover in our post on websites as public accommodations. Either way, a practical approach is to fix the documents customers actually rely on and offer another format quickly when someone asks.

An on-page accessibility toolbar can't fix the inside of a PDF, since the file opens in a separate viewer. That's one more reason a widget alone isn't enough, and why documents belong on your fix list. If you're comparing services that help with scanning and monitoring, see our accessibility tool comparison.

A simple plan

  1. List every PDF your site links to.
  2. Delete or archive the ones nobody needs anymore.
  3. Move frequently changing content, like menus and hours, onto web pages.
  4. Re-export the rest from the original file with tags turned on, then run PAC or Acrobat's checker.
  5. Check reading order and form labels by hand.
  6. Add a line to your accessibility statement telling visitors how to request a document in another format.

The bottom line

PDFs aren't off-limits, but each one is a small piece of your website that needs the same care as a page. Tag them, give them real text, check the reading order and labels, and move anything that changes often onto a web page.

This article is general information, not legal advice. To see how the pages around your PDFs are doing, run a free scan of your site and get a prioritized list of what to fix first.

Frequently asked questions

What makes a PDF accessible?

In short, it has real text, it's tagged so headings, lists, tables and form fields are identified, it reads in a logical order, meaningful images have alt text, and form fields have labels and work with a keyboard.

How can I check a PDF for accessibility for free?

PAC, the free PDF Accessibility Checker, runs automated checks on Windows, and Adobe Acrobat Pro has a built-in checker. Also check the reading order and tab through any form yourself, since tools can't judge everything.

Is a scanned PDF accessible?

Not on its own. A scanned page is a picture of text, so it needs real text from the original file or from OCR, and then tags, before a screen reader can read it properly.

Should my restaurant menu be a PDF or a web page?

A web page is usually better for content that changes often. It works on phones, zooms cleanly and is easier to make accessible. You can still offer a tagged PDF as a printable extra.

Can an accessibility widget fix my PDFs?

No. A PDF opens in a separate viewer, so an on-page toolbar doesn't change the file. The PDF itself needs to be tagged and checked.

Comparing tools? See our accessibility widget comparison.

Sources

Disclaimer: This article is general information, not legal advice. Laws and dates can change. A toolbar alone doesn't make a website conform; we help reduce risk and improve access.

Make your website easier for everyone to use

Start with a free scan. See your score and errors in plain English, then pick a plan when you're ready.

Over 1,000 pages or images?

Get started